• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pantry Pizzeria: Authentic Thin-Crust Pizza & Fresh Breadsticks in Spencer, IN

Pantry Pizzeria, located in Spencer, Indiana, offers a welcoming atmosphere with friendly staff and a focus on satisfying pizza lovers. Known for its thin-crust pizzas and generous, cheesy breadsticks, this spot impresses with both quality and service. Patrons appreciate the fresh, made-to-order buffet that features crowd-pleasers like ground sausage and specialty Stromboli. While some find the crust lighter than expected, the overall flavors and customer care consistently earn praise. If you enjoy classic pizzeria fare balanced with attentive service, Pantry Pizzeria delivers a dependable, tasty experience worth revisiting.

Pantry Pizzeria at a glance

  • Address 330 IN-46, Spencer, IN 47460, United States
  • Phone +1 812-652-1044
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Pantry Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Elizabeth Meek
5

Cam was the best for customer service. You are very fortunate to have him. I had the bbq Stromboli with bread sticks and it was really good exceeding my expectations. Good job.

Sandie Hartman
5

The pizza on the buffet had been there to long. Crust was like cardboard and impossible to cut. Breadsticks were gone and lunchtime was just starting. We asked for breadsticks and new pizzas to be made. Within 15 minutes , the best breadsticks and pizzas we've had in a long time were delivered to the buffet. Would highly recommend.

Bry & Bre Haulk
5

Great pizza any time of the day or week. Friendly staff!

Jeremy Eltz
4

I'd lean toward a 3.5 star. Pizza is just ok. Very thin crust. Breadstick are great with plenty of cheese provided. Staff was very nice!

Google User
4

If you're a fan of Elletsville Pizza Pantry, you'll love Pantry Pizzeria. Same great pizza. We love the ground sausage and are excited for the buffet to be available here!

P V
5

The staff is always so kind every time we come in. We love the pizza, it’s thin but not too thin and the cheese they use is so good. They also have phenomenal breadsticks.

Nance Wallace
4

Pizza was hot and just ready when I arrived to pick it up. Restaurant had a clean appearance-swept and orderly. Cashier appeared happy and was friendly getting myself and the carry out in front of me taken care of promptly. Pizza and breadsticks were properly cooked. All tasted good!

Location

  • Pantry Pizzeria
    Pantry Pizzeria
    330 IN-46, Spencer, IN 47460, United States Hotline: +1 812-652-1044

Pantry Pizzeria in Spencer, Indiana, stands out as a comforting spot for pizza lovers craving both quality and warmth. Nestled conveniently on IN-46, this pizza restaurant offers a menu that speaks to classic tastes with a modern touch. The thin crust pizza, while simple, serves as a canvas for rich toppings like the beloved ground sausage—a favorite among regulars. The buffet option adds another layer of convenience and variety, especially for those eager to sample multiple flavors.

What sets Pantry Pizzeria apart is the genuine hospitality, highlighted by staff members such as Cam, whose customer service customers praise highly. This attentive service enhances the overall dining experience, making every visit feel personal and welcoming. The breadsticks, consistently noted for their generous cheese and fresh-baked warmth, complement the savory pizza well and are a must-try.

Some diners have noticed that buffet pizzas may vary in freshness, but the kitchen’s quick response to replenish with hot, fresh pies shows dedication to customer satisfaction. This responsiveness speaks volumes about Pantry Pizzeria’s commitment to quality and guest care.

Overall, Pantry Pizzeria blends familiar comfort food with attentive service, making it a reliable choice for a casual meal. The combination of well-crafted dishes and a friendly team leaves a positive impression, inviting patrons to come back for another slice.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards